Stack Exchange Network. You free the Spirit after it agrees to save the children in Crookback Bog, and it then ravages Downwarren. The discussion is not limited to competitive viability or even just the ability. . Try it free. The quest requires Geralt to decide the fate of a spirit trapped in the roots of a large oak tree. She will also sink into the ooze. . When I try to kill the tree spirit it starts the battle with 60% health and I can't deal any damage whatsoever. As you approach the hill (ock), use your Witcher Sense to find nearby enemies. people are saying just kill it fast before it heals bla bla~ these people don't *ing impossible to kill it because ♥♥♥♥ heals much faster than the dmg at that level. Find the bones of the spirit trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock using your Witcher Senses. This is my first time playing the game and my decision without reading any of the info about this was to free the spirit. Okay, I have no idea what to do anymore. Asked by: Erika Lowe. Once you've activated the new quest (it's listed under. Illustration by Bartlomiej Gawel. Takedown request View complete answer on ign. Take a look around using your Witcher Senses. It would seem simple enough for a monster slayer to kill the cursed spirit and liberate the townsfolk. Head to Downwarren where, depending on your choice during The Whispering Hillock, the village will either be ravaged and destroyed or no different. Rather than being inspired directly by the 3 Crones, I believe the Deathless Mother is actually partially based on the Ghost in the Tree (AKA ‘The Mother’, ‘She-Who-Knows’, and ‘the Lady of the Wood’). stuboy52. May 27, 2015. This guide covers a full walkthrough of the quest as well as the. She and Dandelion started seeing each other but she felt he needed more discipline in his life. The fate of the Bloody Baron. But, the consequences of this decision are so far-reaching, they impact other parts of the world as well. Version 2. Its near a watery area, working in the opposite direction of the hillock. The Whispering Hillock is one such quest. I knew for sure what would happen if I killed the Whispering. She probably takes the children to piss off her daughters, for killing her, or whatever they did that left her in the form of a tree, but I doubt she just lets them go in this outcome. The Whispering Hillock quest is a sub quest of Ladies Of The Wood. Read up that it was part of another quest and so I said I would think about freeing it or not. I chose it considering all the things that happen with the Whispering Hillock. Children will die if you save spirit before meeting Crones, according to jj284b. Use your witcher sense and you'll get a red sound marker for your target. 简介：【UP说】呢喃山丘和林中夫人任务是《巫师三》中最具有迷惑性的；已有972名巫师3狂猎玩家向您推荐本视频，点击前往哔哩哔哩bilibili一起观看；更多实用攻略教学，爆笑沙雕集锦，你所不知道的游戏知识，热门游戏视频7*24小时持续更新,尽在哔哩哔哩. Last two that you mentioned are very controversial and very hard decisions for me. Geralt can discover and complete the main tasks of. It is possible to complete "The Whispering Hillock" in several different ways, each of which will affect "Return to Crookback Bog" differently. "We’ve released another hotfix for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on PC. Main Quests are the main storyline of the game that can have a major effect towards the endings. Legends of The Witcher | What is The Whispering Hillock?Who or what is The Whispering Hillock? In this legends of the witcher video we will be taking a look. The Whispering Hillock is one of the only quests in the game that is classified as both main and secondary, depending on how it's found. Something about life in dreary backwoods settlements leads their inhabitants to hide the truth with misleading names. Ultr. Contents The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt NotificationsWith that being said, the quest decision I would like to change is from the quest "Whispering Hillock". The Whispering Hillock . RedSpiderLily (Topic Creator) 5 years ago #20. The Whispering Hillock is a main story quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. The Baron then commits suicide. This quest is right up there with the whispering hillock for me in terms of its moral dilemma. Witcher contracts - This page describes the following quests: Contract: Phantom of the Trade Route, Contract: Swamp Thing, Contract: The Merry Widow,. During this conversation, you'll be given a pair of options:During The Witcher 3, Geralt spends plenty of time with Yennefer and Triss. Unknown to the witcher once the ritual is completed the possessed horse will attack the people of Downwarren killing the villagers in revenge and then taking the children. These quests include The Whispering Hillock, Family Matters, and Ladies of the Wood. There is no black or white outcome, you should decide between the lesser evil, following the phylosophy of the Witcher books. United Kingdom: Hydrant signage. After getting details from the ealdorman, Geralt will find the oak tree southeast of the orphanage. What becomes of them comes down to how Geralt approaches the Crones and the Whispering Hillock's proposal. The Baron Dies. Continued Bloody Baron quest. Play a Deathwish unit from your deck. Otherwise, it'll eventually. Rescue this spirit and you start Main Quest: The Whispering Hillock. Ok guys I finished the part where I am anywhere near the whispering. Once you've activated the new quest (it's listed under. If so, do it. PROTEUS TIME: 11. He can make a deal with the Ghost in the Tree or the so-called Whispering Hillock. Can anyone screenshot me where it is or link me to a map that has the info? Thanks a ton, as I've been unable to find it. I do. Apparently it was the crones who then decided to imprison the mother as the Whispering Hillock . The Whispering Hillock Raven's feather is a quest item in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and is needed to help release The Ghost in the Tree, though it can accidentally picked up before the quest is even started, like the. 2) You meet Crones, and then you free Spirit: Anna die, kids are safe, town destroyed, Baron die. *. Before the war, the inhabitants of this village were known for their intricate lacemaking and artisanal smithery. Slay the Monster If during the Ladies of the Wood, when. In the game, the history of the Crones of Crookback Bog is filled in through the entity at the Whispering Hillock, and one of the toughest decisions in The Witcher 3. SCENE: The beach along Sandymount. That's for you to decide. Both are incredibly evil creatures but the whispering hillock has gone insane and will kill with wanton abandon while the Crones prefer to keep the villagers paying tribute to them. Looking to make a Whispering Hillock deck. The Whispering Hillock; Return to Crookback Bog (dependent) Trivia [] "Black Beauty" is the titular horse in novel by Anna Sewell. In "The Whispering Hillock," Geralt finds a mysterious tree spirit hidden in a cave that's been driven there by the Crones of. The best choice for Whispering Hillock is to free the "evil" spirit. Agree to do the ritual. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. You can save 4-5 kids and let many others die, along with future deaths or you can end all of it by killing the Tree Spirit. C. It's an amazing quest where there isn't a definitive better choice. Regarding the Whispering Hillock - I think it's one of the most difficult decisions in the game. As for the kids who says they actually survive. The game version won’t change. Use Igni to temporarily get rid of the gas from a safe distance. Whispering Hillock is one of the most memorable and eerie quests. During the quest Ladies of the Wood, you'll learn that there's an ancient power living under a giant tree on the Whispering Hillock. I went back to the tree and saved it instead. If you killed the spirit in the quest The Whispering Hillock the quest will end here. atiggerx33 8 years ago #1. Note: Banished units are not sent to the graveyard. He should stop you and give you a doll to bring to his daughter. The Whispering Hillock walkthrough. Went to Downwarren, which is still intact. Contents The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt NotificationsConcerning the kids and Downwarren: If you first deal with the Whispering Hillock before meeting with the Crones and talking to the ealdorman in Downwarren, the kids will not be mentioned and you can save Downwarren. It,s your game. Whereas the old crones represent cruel order, and a ritualistic cycle of controlled suffering. Elsewhere, beyond our reach. Near the chalk pentagram is a skull. The best choice for Whispering Hillock is to free the "evil" spirit. Choosing to kill it will start a fight with it. When you arrive, take a look around town. How to start Family Matters. The children get eaten by the Crones, and Anna survives but becomes mad. For the horse head to the next marker south of Ancient Oak, use Axii on one of the wild horses then ride it back to the cave beneath the Whispering Hillock. . The Whispering Hillock – if the world were not as it is but as it should be, this name would denote a place of hidden nooks and lovers sharing heartfelt lies in hushed voices. Most of the time they communicate through an enchanted tapestry and a. I kinda have this feeling that CDPR followed a design philosophy when designing quests that the better/truer/canon? choice, usually allows the player to see "more" (Here being the conversation between. You free the Spirit after it agrees to save the children in Crookback Bog, and it then ravages Downwarren. Geralt concluded this foul being was responsible for murdering the inhabitants of. I was looking at the wiki and it says if you free the spirit before speaking with. This is where "The Whispering Hillock" begins. After speaking to the ealdorman head to the southeast towards the Whispering Hillock. For the Baron to perish after the events of "Return to Crookback Bog," all Geralt needs to do is release the spirit in the tree during "The Whispering Hillock. Quickly do the quest “The Whispering Hillock” to continue on with “Ladies of the Wood. During this quest, the player has to make a difficult decision that will affect the fate of the Strenger couple. I already talked to the spirit bit was unsure if I should release him or kill him, so I searched online and found a page that says the way I dealt with the spirit would interfere in the. This is the major turning point in the Bloody Baron storyline. Just been reading about the Whispering Hillock quest in the Witcher 3 wild hunt. Once all three items are collected Geralt will have to pierce the spirits heart thus releasing it and taking control of the horse. To get started, head to the Crossroads Inn and choose the option "I'm a Witcher" to avoid getting into a fight with the Baron's men. There's a way to save Anna by doing the tree out of sequence, but I don't remember exactly if it was killing the tree or setting it free that got Anna cursed. This topic contains spoilers - you can click, tap, or highlight to reveal them. Neither choice is ideal at all, but both yield interesting resolutions. The Witcher Wiki says it's before you speak with the Ealdorman of Downwarren. Silbe 8 years ago #1. Ealdorman Merchant Ladies of the Wood Return to Crookback Bog The Whispering Hillock In early gameplay videos, the village. The Whispering Hillock’s Spirit . yea use bombs do w/e cost so much for. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Personally, the first time I played the game I found the Whispering Hillock. sexydadee: So I read somewhere that there's a 3rd ending to the bloody baron quest and it involves freeing the whispering hillock first before going to the downwarren ealdorman. Whispering Hillock; Elior528 3 years ago #1. I completed "The Whispering Hillock" after being given the quest by the crones and freed the spirit. Which gives us 3 endings indeed : go to the crones, kill spirit, children are eaten, Anna is crazy, village is ok. I played through Witcher 3 shortly after it released and after coming back to it all this time later, it seems there is a new option to take in the quest mentioned above. . Freed the Whispering Hillock before starting Ladies of the Wood- The Whispering Hillock is free, Baron and Anna will live, the orphans will die, and Downwarren will be destroyed. ). Can't decide between the choices for the Whispering Hillock (spoilers) RedSpiderLily 5 years ago #1. During the Whsipering Hillock part of the questchain, Geraly will have a decision to make, which will come back to haunt the bloody baron in one way or another. If you choose to help the. the wife didn't go insane and 3 members of the family left together. Be aware that this video contains heavy SPOILERS. To this day it lies trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock, where it thrashes about in powerless rage. The flame will ignite the gas and do serious damage to you. Made them from dirt and the crones killed her because she went crazy and was going to destroy velen. I've attempted both choices with the Hillock Spirit in order to see if that affected speaking to the Baron, but it did not. (Image credit: CD Projekt Red) During the Wandering in the Dark quest, Keira Metz will have given you a book called Ladies of the Wood. 'The Whispering Hillock' quest in The Witcher 3 faces Geralt with a grim choice — this guide will provide all the tips you need to see it through. It is a classic Witcher grey area decision, where both choices have good and bad points, hence freeing it does save the children, but again you just released an angry spirit, which makes clear its intent to be a ruthless force of nature. (sad ending, imo)Whispering hillock (Spoilers) StBX_Seraphim 8 years ago #21. Step1: Do "The Whispering Hillock" first and free the spirit. 2. Once the player has done that, they can either do the main quest The Whispering Hillock, or the Secondary Quest Return to Crookback Bog. 3 - Proteus) James Joyce. And the glitch disappeared. The mother or creator of the crones. The Baron Dies. The Baron leaves, taking her to a healer. To complete it you must reach the cave (M9,8) and talk with the ghost. Sure enough, Geralt can find human bones scattered around its base. SPOILERS: So I am finally replaying this gem of a game and I've come to the part where you are asked to kill hillock spirit for crones. Velen trở thành một nơi yên bình. After speaking to the. If you start the Ladies of the Wood quest it will lead you to doing the Whispering Hillock quest. Conditions - Kill the Spirit in the Tree. Keira metz talked about someone calling her out into the woods, Whispering Hillock style. Last updated on January 11, 2020 by A L. As for the Lady's immortal soul, it refused to leave its beloved land and so the sisters imprisoned it. The entire Crookback Bog sequence, which arguably includes Family Matters, The Whispering Hillock and Return to Crookback Bog as well as later missions Bald Mountain and even possibly Something. First off, I ran into the creepy tree when I was adventuring. In the cinematic that plays afterwards it shows the Baron holding his wife's body in his arms. choice3. See moreThe Whispering Hillock is one of the main quests in The Witcher 3 taking place in Velen. For the Baron to perish after the events of "Return to Crookback Bog," all Geralt needs to do is release the spirit in the tree during "The Whispering Hillock. Addeddate 2023-11-01 05:08:10 Identifier whispering-hillock-gwent-card-art-by-bartlomiej-gawel. All gameplay recorded from PC 4K 60fps. The hillock on which the Oak grows is colloquially known as the Whispering Hillock due to the Ghost in the Tree continuously emitting a heartbeat-like sound from underneath it. You must do it to receive information about Ciri from the witches. An Unpaid Debt. Plus the masked elf warns Ciri not to mess. To this day it lies trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock, where it thrashes about in powerless rage. A line can be straight, or a street, but the human heart, oh, no, it’s curved like a road through mountains. If you activate the Crones quest first then free the spirit, the spirit will take the children from that small village, kill the villagers in downwarren. Here is a Whispering Hillock Witcher 3 quest walkthrough, highlighting the Whispering Hillock choice and impact of the decision you make. However, she is driven insane as. Now, Geralt has no say in what the spirit does after. After breaking the roots and the shield, the health stays at 60% and wave of insectoids after wave of. There's few better examples of this than the Ladies of the Wood quest, and your. IDK what your definition of "near" is, but yes there is one in the general area. When you head over. Before the war, the inhabitants of this village were known for their intricate lacemaking and artisanal smithery. The people here worship the ladies of the wood. Then when he tells you to follow him back to the orphanage, leave instead and go to the Whispering Hillock and speak to the Tree Spirit. Use your witcher sense and you'll get a red sound marker for your target. Texture PackNew! I have made an idependant texture pack similar to GwentTWCG by jamut69, but updated and functional with G++R. Read on for information on objectives, possible rewards, and the best choice for the player to make, as well as useful tips and strategies for completing the quest. It is possible to complete "The Whispering Hillock" in several different ways, each of which will affect "Return to Crookback Bog" differently. When you get close to the marker, prepare to take on a level 8 water hag. Some of these quests may have dialogue choices that will alter the ending of the game. You're right -- freeing the spirit before the Crones ask Geralt to do the Whispering Hillock event results in Anna surviving and leading to the subplot's optimistic ("Baron looks for a healer") resolution. Secondary Quest: The Whispering Hillock. Miramar81 said: Wouldn't make for a Dark Fantasy if you could save both and it wouldn't make sense. You free the spirit, the orphans are saved, Anna dies, Bloody Baron commits suicide. Downwarren is a village in the No Man's Land featured in the The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. IMPORTANT - to play this option, you can't start the Whispering Hillock side quest until you find the village on the swamps (M9,17). The Whispering Hillock. While this quest is optional, it will allow you to continue the story to. Take down this adversary and then strike the roots surrounding the entity. The Crones are not done causing misery. Summary Source: Gerry Carlin & Mair Evans. In short, the crones seem to be the lesser evil, though I don't know if that is how you would make your decision. The Witcher 3 - The Whispering Hillock: Calm A Wild Horse Using Axii and Bring Back To Tree PS5 4. This will influence what will happen to Anna and the Bloody Baron in the side quest Return to. We reimagined cable. Wolves And A Werewolf Head toward the supposedly-haunted tree, and there will be some wolves and a werewolf to contend with, while a mysterious voice. I didn't know whether the book was truthful, or propaganda written by some brainwashed fanatic, but investigating the Whispering Hillock and finding a dead child and werewolf confirmed that the spirit/thing under that tree was beyond my understanding. So the only way to save the children AND Anna is to begin The Ladies of the Wood quest as normal up until the point where you get Johnny's voice back for him but when he wants you to follow him back to the orphanage to meet the Crones, leave and go do the Whispering Hillock thing and free the Tree Spirit. B) I went to Crookback Bog talked to the kids and learned about Johnny. After you talk to the spirit, it opens a sort of cave opening, you can use it to get inside riding the horse. Pashta 8 years ago #11. Depending on how Geralt dealt with The Whispering Hillock, the outcome of this mission will change. It would seem simple enough for a monster slayer to kill the cursed spirit and liberate the townsfolk. Ladies of the Wood is a main quest in Velen in The Witcher 3. SPOILERS AHEAD IF YOU HAVENT BEAT THIS QUEST. You may run into Drowners along the way, if you take a direct route. ''She Who Knows is a book in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, describing a legend of the Ghost in the Tree from a perspective favoring the Crones' image as benevolent deities of Velen. You free the spirit, the orphans are saved, Anna dies, Bloody Baron commits suicide. The Whispering Hillock quest . If during the Ladies of the Wood, when Geralt is tasked with killing, he. When you head over to that location to investigate the tree, a voice will order you to leave. The Crones, having no children to eat, will punish Anna, turning her into a hag. " While this decision guarantees The Baron's demise, Geralt will affect exactly how it all plays out. For more information on this decision check out the walkthrough guide of the quest below: The Whispering Hillock Walkthrough and Best Choice In this video I delve into the Whispering Hillock, or the Ghost in the Tree. And I watched the dialogue part on uoutube. Step 2: Start "The Ladies of the Wood". Conditions - Free the Spirit in the Tree. Gran, who is the Baron’s wife, Anna, will be transformed into a Water Hag and ultimately die. If not mistaken, attempting to free the spirit before getting the quest from the Crones kill the Hillock means the children are safe and sound w/ Nanny. Returned to Whispering Hillock, freed the spirit. You have a choice of having two evil powers in the world or just one (and maybe not even one but don't really know). The baron goes away either way and his wife is either dead or mental. IGN guides you through The Whispering Hillock, one of the main story quests in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Romance Guides. Whispering Hillock spoilers. Note: For accurate card stats, see infobox to the right; the below is for illustrative purposes only. I'm on my second playthrough of TW3 and decided to kill the Whispering Hillock this time instead of sparing her. Witcher 3 should I kill the spirit in the tree?It's been a while since I played that quest though, so I don't remember exactly where the new cave opening is. 11) The Whispering Hillock - Nasty choice to make in this quest, you either choose to free the spirit or choose to kill the spirit as the Crones told you to do. Though originally written in Polish, the franchise gathered a large international following from likewise acclaimed game adaptions by CD Projekt. They are named Brewess, Weavess, and Whispess. Also, if you read the book "She Who Knows" in the game it pretty clearly points out that the spirit in the whispering hillock is the Crones mother, the Lady of the Woods. The Whispering Hillock ; Ciri's Story: Fleeing The Bog ; Walkthrough: Act One - Novigrad. If you kill it the Crones will eat the children/Anna. It won’t end when you get The Whispering Hillock, but completing this quest is a prerequisite for finishing that quest. Before looking for Johnny I did Whispering Hillocks. Locals believe dark forces still haunt this place. After a confrontation with the Hillock, Geralt learns that three witches called "the Crones" have manipulated him through the tapestry. Read the Ladies of the Wood book. Your task is to find information on Ciri by meeting the witches in Crookback Bog. So, it's my first time playing and I was doing the Ladies of the Woods main quest when I reached the Whispering Hillock. In this hidden grotto, the witch is. By using Axii before mounting, you can ride Black Beauty for an extended period. MAJOR SPOILERS FOR THE STORY!!!I found this a third way to work around the dilemma with the witches and the possessed tree spirit. If you have not and do not want spoilers stop reading! Ok, so I have defeated the werewolf with Ciri, I have done a side mission where I had to. They are monstrous fiends controlling the entire region and drawing power from the consumption of children and sacrificial blood of villagers. It was released as one of the 16 free DLCs on 12 June 2015. It is indeed a difficult choice. In this cave you'll find a ghost, which is asking you to free it (quest: "The Whispering Hillock"). However, the second the fight starts, the tree's heart is at about 60%. “It’s not the mountain we conquer,. ↓Reference video. - The Hillock’s located to the southeast of Downwarren. After speaking to the ealdorman head to the southeast towards the Whispering Hillock. The Whispering Hillock was a large tree on the top of a large incline hill. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is coming on February. com. . This is interesting, as Ard Cerbin is elder speech for Bald Mountain, which is a different location entirely from The Whispering Hillock, with another ancient oak atop its peak. I wonder if having the Whispering Hillock quest completed prior to tackling this quest can void the achievement. In this video you'll find all the choices and immediate consequences for this quest. Killing the Crones and freeing the spirit will save the children (and Anna). 2. You probably have the feather, which you picked up while completing Main Quest: Ladies of the Wood. There will be a Water Hag and 2 drowners outside. When I reached that point, I killed the tree. The choice is obvious and clear cut. The Whispering Hillock quest is a sub quest of Ladies Of The Wood. There’s no way to. ago. Here is a Whispering Hillock Witcher 3 quest walkthrough, highlighting the Whispering Hillock choice and impact of the decision you make. Later, I did the Ladies quest and freed the spirit. Why does this happen, when that same action would lead to the bad ending in the subplot's normal course? Because freeing the ghost early. Wolves And A Werewolf Head toward the supposedly-haunted tree, and there will be some wolves and a werewolf to contend with, while a mysterious voice. He’ll ask you to investigate a haunted oak tree on the Whispering Hillock. He just keeps regenerating, it's frustrating really. The Whispering Hillock: Ancient Oak 5 17 Ciri's Story: Fleeing the Bog: Crookback Bog 5 18 Pyres of Novigrad: Novigrad 10 19 Novigrad Dreaming: Novigrad 7 20 Broken Flowers: Novigrad 11 21 Get Junior: Novigrad 12 22 Ciri's Story: Visiting Junior: Novigrad 9 23 Count Reuven's Treasure: Novigrad 12 24 A Favor for RadovidHer blood watered the oak atop Arb Derbin, and from then on the tree grew wholesome and hearty fruit for the people. SPOILERS, A question about doing "The Whispering Hillock" early. You encounter the Whispering Hillock after the Crones mention it. BLM actually stands for Bureau of Land Management. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. This is the major turning point in the Bloody Baron storyline. The Baron was a terrible ruler and father so he can go. Stealing to make a living, Basim's life changes after he breaks into the Winter Place of. Note: this quest will fail if not completed before starting The Isle of Mists. I've got enough scraps to. Also, seems like the player can save them all if doing the Whispering Hillock before meeting the Baron or going to Crookback for the first time, but this seems more an oversight from devs. The Whispering Hillock is one such quest. The Whispering Hillock is pretty much our last required stop for this visit to Velen; it will wrap up Family Matters as well as the entire Velen sequence of the In Ciri's Footsteps quest. I think its more of an encouragement from the devs that exploring might get you better options. The text mentions how the power took advantage of the people in the area and that the witches of the bog fought and overcame it to lead the prosperity of the area. Once you receive the reward, go back to Ladies of the Wood. She (Black Stallion) represents the wild chaos of nature. . Note: completing this quest will unlock the achievement Card Collector. What if you kill the whispering hillock first before meeting crones? Rookie. Geralt KNOWS the children will die if he kills The Whispering Hillock. The quest triggers when you reach the hillock and voice tells you to leave. In my opinion, no, partially because of consequences. This is a very long discussion on the morality at play in the Witcher 3, regarding the Whispering Hillock, Black Beauty, the Crones, and Velen as a…Kill the spirit, justify it as geralt thinking that he could save the kids or that he simply did not believe the spirit. The Crones, also called the Ladies of the Wood, are three witches who live in a cabin in the swamps of Velen. 3 guides. Sci-fi. Create a Bronze or Silver Organic card. My outcome was a little odd so I was wondering if anyone else ran into this. You’ll need to go. Offering to help the spirit starts the secondary quest The Whispering Hillock. You encounter the Whispering Hillock after the Crones mention it. The Whispering Hillock is a main quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and here are all the options, choices and consequences. Geralt of Rivia needs to enter sorceress's hut and have a short chat with her. Killing the Tree Spirit is the best choice. If we're thinking from an omniscient perspective, where we know the consequences, I personally think killing the tree spirit is best. Your choice here will have a major impact on the Bloody Baron's family, fate of Downwarren's villagers, and the orphans in Crookback Bog. The Whispering Hillock is a main quest in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and here are all the options, choices and consequences. So I read somewhere that there's a 3rd ending to the bloody baron quest and it involves freeing the whispering hillock first before going to the downwarren ealdorman. However, you can also free the spirit when you interact with it. As for the Lady's immortal soul, it refused to leave its beloved land, and so the sisters imprisoned it. I'm assuming this is a weird bug.